what is this, rc-dot-com??? how about: best route name at rumney?? or even better: "how do i mark the middle of my rope???" (oops, i see someone already asked that....)
whether you like a route or not depends on a lot of factors that may have nothing to do with whether the route is a "bag of $hit."
the climbing just may not suit your style.... personally, i won't even get on cereal killer. it's not a bad route, in fact, i think it's a great route, but i just suck at it. there are a hundred other routes i can do that don't make me feel like the total fat-assed bumbly i am.
i think a better question is: what sort of thing new route activity gets people really upset. for me, it's things like: crowding existing routes, retro-bolting existing routes without fa'ers permission, and dirty, sharp climbing with out any redeaming aesthetic factors.
a couple of years ago somebody told me,"we should just bolt classics; we don't need to add any more no-star routes to rumney..."
i think that's pretty good advice.